Revisiting Outnumbered: 2008 vs. 2012

By Jedediah Bila

In May of 2011, Outnumbered: Chronicles of a Manhattan Conservative was released, a series of anecdotes that chronicled my journey in Manhattan as a teacher and high school Dean throughout the 2008 presidential election season and beyond. One of the most common questions I have been asked by those who have read the book is “Has Manhattan changed this election cycle as compared to 2008?”

Some things certainly have, and I believe those changes are directly in line with a significantly lower enthusiasm for Barack Obama among his 2008 base. Gone are many of the stands on Manhattan street corners selling Obama t-shirts, pins, and other accessories. Gone are many of the voters willing to passionately defend Obama’s 2008 promises of “hope” and “change” or to attack those who dare to question his presidential record. Gone are many of the wide-eyed expressions, tears of excitement, and overwhelmingly optimistic words of praise for the man who many believed was going to change politics as we know it forever.

Sure, Barack Obama has some very loyal supporters in Manhattan, some equally as loyal as they were in 2008. However, I believe it is safe to say that the wave of Obamamania that swept through this city in 2008 has quieted significantly, leaving many who were once hopeful now doubtful, and some who were once captivated now apathetic.

One thing is certain: The challenges for the Right in Manhattan remain ample. Just last week, I spoke with three women, all Democrats, who have grown disillusioned with President Obama’s promises and policies. They certainly won’t be volunteering for his campaign, donating their hard-earned cash, or championing his potential to their families and friends. However, they also haven’t been attracted to the Republican alternative. The mere mention of the word “Republican” immediately soured their expressions, and they were quick to parrot academia and media-driven false talking points about Republicans being allies of the rich who stand in the way of minority rights and low-income voter interests. Not surprisingly, when I detached the policies of freedom, limited government, and debt and deficit reduction from the word “Republican,” the women found themselves embracing many of the ideas I presented. However, the stereotypes of what it means to be a Republican–or worse for them, a conservative–are quite heavily ingrained.

All three women were stunned to discover that you can be a Republican and support gay marriage. They were surprised to hear me talk fondly of the racial and lifestyle diversity of my friends. They admitted that my leather jacket, combat boots, and Wonder Woman logo tee instantly caused them to assume that I was a liberal. They were astonished to discover that I am an organic food lover and Whole Foods enthusiast, and that if I were rich, I would likely open an enormous animal shelter and spend my days caring for some of God’s most defenseless and wonderful creations. And yes, of course, they were shocked to learn that I am not, nor have I ever been, rich.

Discovering that I didn’t fit the pre-packaged image they had been sold about what a conservative should look like, talk like, and think like caused those three women to open their ears and actually hear what I had to say. Those moments are priceless. They are the moments that open minds. They are the moments that change hearts. And they are the moments when we on the right define ourselves, rather than allow the Left to do it for us time and again.

It is a fact that many individuals born and raised in liberal cities like New York, San Francisco, Seattle, and Boston–or those emerging from liberal academic institutions–will possess negative stereotypes about conservatives. It is fiction that you can’t dismantle those stereotypes. I do it daily, simply by engaging those of differing political perspectives and sharing who I am and what I value. My life, my choices, my passions–heck, even my wardrobe–challenge those stereotypes every day.

So yes, the energy in Manhattan has changed this election cycle. Obamamania has quieted down. Month after month of high national unemployment, a ballooning debt and deficit, and the lack of a clear forward vision from our President will do that.

However, the bigger challenge of defining conservatism and the Republican Party to those who have lived much of their lives detesting both for the wrong reasons–well, that challenge clearly remains.

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter
and Download the AMAC News App

Sign Up Today Download

If You Enjoy Articles Like This - Subscribe to the AMAC Daily Newsletter!

Sign Up Today
Read more articles by Jedediah Bila
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
D. Zimmerman
8 years ago

Your book is great. Thanks for the work you do. I was surprised about you comment saying that you can be Republican and support gay marriage. I am a Christian and love everyone as the bible directs us to and I also strongly support marriage as between and man and and a woman. Have a great day. Be blessed.

8 years ago

What? Liberals can be bigoted against people that don’t march to their tune? Who’d have thunk it? ;-)

8 years ago

WHERE can I get a Wonder Woman t-shirt?

8 years ago

Where can I get a Wonder Woman logo t-shirt?

phil anderson
8 years ago

this board doesn’t work

8 years ago

Good article. Keep them coming.

8 years ago

I think there is a bias here, against Yahoo.com mail address’s. I have tried on two occasions, 2 months ago and today
to send a longer reply. Close to the size of WaltEly says: post.
When it happened before I called in but no solution was found. I was able to send a one word reply, but that’s all.
Keep up the good conservative work, Jedediah.

8 years ago
Reply to  fred

Yes, it does seem that posting is a bit hit and miss for some reason. Half my posts make it and the other half appear to vanish in the bit bucket in the sky.

8 years ago


8 years ago

Excellent article! I totally agree we must not allow the left to define what conservatism means to the general public. This has gone on far too long and we are now living through what an uninformed public ultimately leads to.

John Hutchinson
8 years ago

Jed: In an effort not to obloviate….a 5 Star article!…from the ‘Red Eye’ flitedeck…John

John Higgins
8 years ago

Marvelous observations!
Real glad to hear you are noticing something happening in the Big Apple. Same type of moving away from Obama is happening to some of my friends.

8 years ago

Great column, as a Seattle-area product, I can really identify with this. As an example, it’s frustrating to field questions like, “do you think any of the Republican candidates for President aren’t crazy?”

Thanks, and keep up the great work.

8 years ago

You are so right that conservatives have ‘allowed’ the left to define them. This is a big handicap that needs to be overcome. Perhaps we should do like the chameleon Democrats do and give ourselves a new name like patriots or ‘real Americans’, human beings or ….. taxpayers ;-)

They dress up as ‘liberals’, ‘progressives’, ‘the left’ and Democrats and when you get to the bottom of it you find they are not ‘fair’, not for the little guy, not liberal unless you consider an OK for perversion and abortion liberal, not open minded and certainly NOT progressive. It is they who want to put everybody back in a big government dependency paradigm and NOT enhance our freedom or productivity! It is they who demand government solve problems instead of WE THE PEOPLE. Basically ‘liberals’ are cowards and do not like it pointed out and they want someone else to solve their problems and be the ‘bad guy’ for them. These are people who couldn’t change the oil in their car to save their lives!

Historically there have always been parts of the population who LOVE the ‘government system and program’ and will support it vigorously (think Nazi Germany, the Bolshevik revolution and those who just loved Mao until he starved them)! Then there are those who think and watch and act when things are going wrong. You don’t have to call that ‘conservative’, you could just call it human! We are the humans, they love being cattle and sheep – the new definition of Democrats! Cows softly mooing in their fields for more ‘government hay’!

8 years ago

Great book and excellent column. Keep going…. Thx

Patty Burch
8 years ago

You give me continued hope as a almost 60 year old conservative woman! Thank you!

Raphael Gluck
8 years ago

That should make for a new tile of the sequel to Outnumbered
Something like
“Breaking Even”

8 years ago

Excellent book, thanks for the updates!

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x